How it works
How to file a Nassau grievance yourself
Free, step by step, for the 2028/29 roll. Filing opens January 4, 2027 at 9 AM and closes March 1, 2027 at 11:59 PM.
- 1Check freeSee whether your assessment implies a value above recent sales near you.
- 2File free on AROWFile online with the Assessment Review Commission (ARC) between January 4 and March 1, 2027. No lawyer, no hearing.
- 3Lower your billA reduction shows on the October 2028 school bill and the January 2029 general bill.
File Your Own Grievance, Pay Nothing to a Preparer
Every step below is free. The $100 guide is optional, if you'd rather we pull the sales for you.
Emerald Grievance is built on Nassau County's own records: the full assessment roll, every recorded residential sale, and years of grievance outcomes. On the 2026/27 roll, that record covers 427,022 parcels. 252,353 of them filed. Of the filings that were decided, 92.9% got an assessment cut (223,885 of 240,895). Among the homes that won, the countywide median cut was 9.14%. Those figures describe that roll. They are not a forecast, and they are not a promise that your assessment will fall.
A Nassau tax bill is not what gets appealed. The assessed value is. That number is a point count, and it implies a market value once you apply the level of assessment the county is using for the year. The guide walks you through testing that implied value against real sales, putting every fact that affects value on the record, and filing while the window is open. A grievance cannot raise an assessment. It also cannot guarantee a reduction. What it can do is put a supported number in front of the Assessment Review Commission, early, with evidence a reviewer can actually use. You can keep doing that every year until the home, and the homes around it, are valued correctly.
The guide uses the method below on every residential case. These are the steps, and the reasons for them. You file this grievance yourself. A $150 service that files for you is coming soon, pending our application. It is not open.
- File early, and treat the deadline as firm. For the 2028/29 roll, the window opens January 4, 2027 at 9 AM and closes March 1, 2027 at 11:59 PM. That filing is what will show up on the October 2028 school bill and the January 2029 general bill. The deadline can be extended, but it often is not, and the guide does not plan on an extension. Waiting does not make the case stronger.
- Start in AROW, and check the record. The guide walks you through registering the property with the Assessment Review Commission, opening it by address, and confirming that the county's description of the home is largely right. Then you pull the sales and choose comparables.
- A comparable is a home that sold. A neighboring house with a lower assessment is not a comparable. The commission cannot use unsold homes as sales evidence, so the guide does not treat them that way.
- The sales have to be the right kind of sales. Other sales generally have to be from the past two years. The home being grieved is the exception: its own purchase can still be used even if it is older than that two-year window. Short sales, foreclosures, transfers between family members, and sales of damaged houses are not used as comparables.
- The quality of those sales matters. Look first for sold homes in the same immediate neighborhood and the same school district, of roughly the same size, style, and age. Reach for weaker sales only when stronger ones are not available. If, after the correct level of assessment is applied, the good sales do not support a reduction, the home may already be fairly assessed. Even then, the guide still has you file until the commission consistently turns down filings that are not supported.
- Use the five closest qualifying sales. These are the first five sold homes that pass the tests: arm's length, the past two years, the same class, then the closest match on distance, living area, lot, age, and school district. They are not hand-picked for the lowest price. If those five support a reduction, the case is in a stronger position if it goes to a second review.
- Test the sales against the value the assessment implies. Implied market value is assessed value divided by the level of assessment, or assessed value times the multiplier, which is 1 divided by that level. Look for good sales that adjust below that figure. The 2028/29 level of assessment has not been published yet. Until it is, the most recent figure the commission applied for Class 1 was 0.054% on the 2027/28 roll, a multiplier of about 1,852. The guide replaces that number when the new level is published, and it uses the level the commission is actually applying for the year being grieved. If five good sales below that implied value cannot be found, the home may be fairly assessed. Still use as many supporting sales as you can find.
- Complete Part D. This is not a section to leave blank. A person who understands appraisal may read the file at the second-review stage, and Part D is where you give that reviewer the facts.
- In "other facts," put down everything that affects value. Outdated interiors, a flood zone, unrepaired fire or water damage, a busy road, a house that needs to be elevated, and any other condition that would change what the home would sell for belongs on the application. If substantial repairs are needed, say so and upload estimates. After you submit the application, upload photographs of unrepaired damage and any other supporting documents.
- Also put a recent purchase, a listing, or a sale, in writing, when it helps. If the home was bought within the past three years and the price is below the implied or tentative market value, state that purchase price. If the home is listed, or has sold, for less than the tentative market value, state that too. And state that, at the proper level of assessment, the home is over-assessed, with the implied-value figure written out. Do not leave the commission to run that math.
- Add sales that are not already in AROW when you have them. The system lets you enter additional comparables manually. After the application is submitted, you can still upload documents and photographs. A confirmation email follows.
- A decision typically arrives in five to fourteen months, by email, by letter, or both, depending on the contact method you chose at filing. For the 2028/29 roll, the commission's review runs through March 31, 2028. Because tax rates move, the dollar effect of a reduction cannot be known with precision until the bills are issued.
- Do not expect an automatic cut. Years ago, many filers received an automatic 6% reduction, whether or not they submitted sales, because the commission did not have the staff to review every filing. That across-the-board reduction is gone, and the guide does not count on it coming back. What has not changed is the rule that a grievance cannot increase the assessed value.
- File every year. The commission changes the level of assessment, and homes that looked fairly assessed have still received reductions. When other homes in the same school district get cuts, the tax rate rises and everyone else's bill goes up. Keep filing until you are satisfied that the county has valued the home correctly, and valued the other homes in the community correctly. Until the commission reliably denies filings that are not supported, every grievance has some chance of a reduction. Frozen or stale rolls make that more important, not less. Each year is its own appeal. There is no guarantee of a reduction, because the standard can change from one roll to the next. At a flat $100, filing every year stays within reach.
- Accurate valuation of every property is still necessary. Correcting the roll is hard, and some bills may go up when it happens. It is still the only way school tax rates can eventually stabilize, instead of rising by 7 percent or more in a year.
This is general information about how the guide builds a case, not legal or tax advice, and not a promise that an assessment will fall. Confirm the level of assessment, the tax rate, and the deadline with the Department of Assessment and the Assessment Review Commission before relying on a dollar figure.
Read this first
You're grieving two years ahead.
The January 4, 2027 roll is the 2028/29 roll. AROW opens that morning at 9 AM. File by March 1, 2027 at 11:59 PM, online or by mail postmarked that day, to change the October 2028 school bill and the January 2029 general bill. Each year is a separate appeal, so file every year.
- Jan 4, 2027Tentative roll opens at 9 AM. It is the 2028/29 roll. AROW opens then.
- Mar 1, 2027Last day to file. 11:59 PM online, or mail postmarked that day.
- Oct 2, 2028School tax bill this grievance can change.
- Jan 2, 2029General tax bill this grievance can change.
The practical guide: forms, evidence, the ask, and SCAR
- Jan 4, 2027AROW opens, 9 AM
- Mar 1, 2027AROW closes, 11:59 PM
- Mar 31, 2028ARC review through this date
- May 1, 2028SCAR due, $30
These dates are the 2028/29 column on the county assessment review calendar. Confirm them there before you rely on a day. Filing with the Assessment Review Commission is free, and you do not need a lawyer. This is general information, not legal or tax advice, and not a promise that an assessment will fall.
File it yourself
Step 1
Check the tentative roll
On January 4, 2027 at 9 AM the Department of Assessment publishes the tentative assessment for the 2028/29 roll, and AROW opens. Look the property up whether or not a notice arrived. Check square footage, bathrooms, lot size, basement, and garage. The 2028/29 level of assessment is not published yet.
Step 2
File with ARC by March 1, 2027
File online in AROW, or by mail postmarked March 1, 2027. Paper forms are AR1, AR2, or AR3 at 240 Old Country Road, 5th floor, Mineola. Filing is free. You need a parcel ID or address, your estimate of full market value, and an email address. Part B asks for full market value, not assessed value, and that number has to be below the county's tentative market value.
Step 3
Attach the evidence
Attach comparable sales, photos, an appraisal, or record-card corrections. For income property, attach the rent roll and income and expense statements the county asks for. AROW accepts documents, spreadsheets, photos, and scans. It does not accept video.
Step 4
Wait for ARC's offer
ARC reviews on paper. It can lower the assessment or leave it. It cannot raise it. An offer has to be accepted or rejected in the time the offer itself specifies. That time is not a fixed 30 days. Accepting ends the grievance for that year and gives up SCAR for that year.
Step 5
Read the final roll
ARC sends final determination letters by March 31, 2028. The final roll is April 3, 2028. A reduction shows on the October 2028 school bill and the January 2029 general bill. Most ARC results show up on the bill, not as a refund.
Step 6
SCAR, only if you did not accept
Court review stays open only if you filed with ARC and did not accept the offer. For this roll the last day for Small Claims Assessment Review is May 1, 2028. The County Clerk fee is $30. You cannot ask SCAR for a larger reduction than you asked ARC for.
What to gather
- The county's description of the home: living area, bathrooms, lot size, basement, and garage. Factual errors are the simplest corrections. Check them on the Department of Assessment record.
- Comparable sales: homes that sold, not unsold neighbors with a lower assessment. Look first in the same neighborhood and school district, of similar size, style, and age. The county's sales locator, on the AROW sales locator, starts with its own filters and widens them if it finds fewer than 35 sales. You can submit up to five.
- This site uses the five closest qualifying sales: sold homes, arm's length, the past two years, the same class, then the closest match on distance, living area, lot, age, and school district. They are not hand-picked for the lowest price. Include a close sale even if it is above the value the assessment implies. One high sale does not settle the case.
- Photos of conditions that change what the home would sell for, and repair estimates when the work is substantial. AROW does not accept video.
- A purchase, listing, or sale from the last three years, when that price is below the implied or tentative market value. Write the price down. Do not leave the commission to find it.
How to pick the ask
Implied market value is assessed value divided by the level of assessment. The 2028/29 level is not published yet. Until it is, the most recent Class 1 figure the commission applied was 0.054% on the 2027/28 roll. ARC says it applies 0.057% for Class 1 at SCAR or Article 7 on that roll, and the county's published Class 1 level for 2027/28 is 0.1%. Use the figure the county is applying for the year you are grieving. The levels are discussed on the ARC FAQ.
Part B of the grievance asks for your full market value, not an assessed value. The number you request has to be below the county's tentative market value. Support it with the sales. Do not ask for less than those sales support: at SCAR you cannot ask for a larger reduction than you asked ARC for. If the equalized value is over $450,000, the reduction you can ask SCAR for is capped at 25% of the assessment. That rule is in the SCAR instructions and on the court SCAR page.
After you file
Use one filer only. A second application for the same property can be denied. A confirmation email follows an online filing, and you can still upload documents after you submit. You can also mail papers with a cover sheet that lists the application and parcel number. Form instructions are on AR1.
ARC's review for this roll runs through March 31, 2028. You do not have to appear. If ARC proposes a reduction, answer within the time that offer specifies. Accepting it gives up SCAR for that year. The decision then flows into the October 2028 school bill and the January 2029 general bill.
SCAR
SCAR is the next step only when you filed with ARC and did not accept the offer. For the 2028/29 roll the petition is due May 1, 2028. File form UCS 900 with the Nassau County Clerk, on paper or electronically, with the $30 fee, and mail copies to the parties the instructions list. A hearing officer schedules an informal hearing. Commercial, rental, and other property that cannot use SCAR goes to State Supreme Court under Article 7. Emerald Grievance does not file that case.
If a SCAR decision or a later court settlement lowers an assessment after the bills went out, the difference comes back as a refund or a credit. The timing of that refund is not verified on an official county page. Confirm it with the Department of Assessment.
Villages and cities
The City of Glen Cove, the City of Long Beach, and most incorporated villages assess their own taxes. An ARC filing does not preserve those appeals. File them with the local Board of Assessment Review. Village boards often meet the third Tuesday of February. Confirm the date with the village clerk.
Questions
When do I file a Nassau grievance?
For the 2028/29 roll, AROW opens January 4, 2027 at 9 AM and closes March 1, 2027 at 11:59 PM. File online, or by mail postmarked that day. ARC's FAQ says the deadline is not extended. Earlier years were extended. This page does not promise one.
Which form do I use?
AR1 is the value of a 1–3 family home or a Class 1 condo. AR2 is the value of other property, including commercial, rentals, co-op buildings, and vacant land. AR3 is tax class, exemptions, and other non-value claims, and its proof goes to the Department of Assessment, not ARC. Value and a non-value issue are two applications.
Can filing raise my assessment?
No. ARC can lower the assessment or leave it. It cannot raise it.
Do I have to appear?
No. You make the case in writing. ARC can ask you to appear if requested information is missing. SCAR does include an informal hearing.
What if I reject ARC's offer?
Reject it if you disagree. Representing yourself at ARC has no fee, including when the review continues after a rejection. If you reject the final determination, SCAR for this roll is open through May 1, 2028. The fee is $30. Accepting the offer gives up SCAR for that year.
Who can use SCAR?
Small Claims Assessment Review is for owner-occupied 1–3 family homes used only as homes, and Class 1 condos. Other property uses an Article 7 proceeding in State Supreme Court. The state recommends a private attorney for that case. Emerald Grievance does not file either one.
Deadline and roll alerts
A reminder before the Nassau filing deadline, and a note when a new assessment roll is published. No message is sent until these alerts are turned on.
Sources: the assessment review calendar, the ARC FAQ, AROW, the SCAR instructions, and the same dates and rules on the Emerald Grievance home page. The November 11, 2026 extract of the 2026/27 roll on that page covers 427,022 parcels. 252,353 filed. Of the filings that were decided, 92.9% received an assessment cut (223,885 of 240,895). Among the homes that won, the countywide median cut was 9.14%. Those figures describe that roll. They are not a forecast.
What wins
Grounds + proof = a reduction
Pick the right legal ground. Back a specific market value with evidence.
The four grounds (NY Real Property Tax Law)
Excessive
Valued above what it's worth, or an exemption was denied.
Most homeowner casesUnequal
Assessed at a higher share of value than others on the roll.
Uses the ratioUnlawful
Should be exempt, wrong district, or entered without authority.
Rare, technicalMisclassified
Wrong tax class, so the wrong, higher rate.
File on form AR3Evidence, comps, and what is strong or weak
The evidence that moves the number
Comparable sales
The core of a homeowner case. Recent, nearby, similar homes that sold for less than the county's value of yours, ideally adjusted for differences in size, condition and features.
Property record card errors
Wrong square footage, extra bathrooms, a finished basement you don't have, wrong lot size. Check the county's record of your house first. Factual errors are the easiest wins.
Condition photos
Dated photos of problems that cut value: an old roof, water damage, foundation cracks, a dated kitchen, a busy road or commercial neighbor. Repair estimates make them stronger.
Appraisal or purchase price
A recent arm's-length purchase price, a recent listing price, or a professional appraisal near the valuation date. These are the first items the state's SCAR instructions list.
Income & expense, rent roll
For commercial and rental property, value follows income. ARC's rules ask for rent rolls, at least two years of itemized income and expenses, and lease abstracts. See the commercial panel below.
Exemptions
STAR, Enhanced STAR, senior, disability, veteran and volunteer exemptions cut your taxable value without touching market value. A denied or miscalculated exemption is its own claim, on form AR3.
What a "good comp" looks like · ARC's own sales search starts here
ARC's free online sales search (for one- and two-family homes) starts with these filters, and widens them if it finds fewer than 35 sales. It's a good benchmark for picking your own comps. You can submit up to 5 through the tool.
Also: the sale must be recorded by the county as a valid (arm's-length) sale. Same style, age and condition helps. Comps are optional: if you don't send any, ARC still reviews your home against sales it selects.
Strong vs. weak evidence
Strong
- +3–5 valid sales of similar homes within about a third of a mile, sold within a year of the valuation date, all below your county value
- +Adjustments that explain differences (an extra bath, a bigger lot, a renovated kitchen)
- +A documented error on your property record card (wrong sq ft, baths or lot size)
- +Your own recent arm's-length purchase price, or an appraisal near the valuation date
- +Dated photos of defects plus contractor repair estimates
- +Commercial: complete rent roll, two or more years of itemized income and expenses, lease abstracts
Weak
- −"My taxes are too high." ARC reviews value, not tax rates or budgets
- −"My neighbor pays less." Without sales or values behind it, it proves nothing
- −Online automated home-value estimates with no actual sales
- −Sales from another town, years old, or between relatives (not arm's-length)
- −Bigger or renovated homes used as comps with no adjustments
- −Asking for less than you can support. In SCAR you can't ask for more than you asked ARC for, so don't lowball your claimed value either
Nassau-specific rules
How Nassau is different
No May town board here. The county assesses; an independent agency, ARC, reviews appeals year-round.
Check the county's math: assessed value ÷ level of assessment = implied market value
Illustrative numbers only. The county publishes the market value it estimated for your home on its property search site, so you can also compare that figure directly with your comps.
Levels, caps, forms, villages, and commercial property
Level of assessment
Fractional, by class
Assessments are set at a small, uniform fraction of market value for each class. For the 2027/28 roll, the Department of Assessment published 0.1% for Class 1 (homes) and 1% for Classes 2 and 4.
ARC says the levels it applies to 2027/28 filings are 0.054% for Class 1 at ARC, 0.057% for Class 1 at SCAR or Article 7, and 0.060% for Classes 2 and 4. The gap between the published and applied levels matters for an "unequal" claim.
The 2028/29 level of assessment is not published yet. Checked November 20, 2026. The 0.054% and 0.057% figures above are the 2027/28 levels.
Caps
6% a year, 20% in 5
A Class 1 home's total assessed value can't rise more than 6% in one year or 20% over five years, except for new construction or renovation. Classes 2 and 4 phase increases in over five years.
If you accept an ARC reduction, the lower figure becomes the base for next year's 6% cap. If the new tentative roll ignored it, appeal and contact the Department of Assessment.
Frozen values
No countywide reassessment
The county still publishes a new tentative roll every January. But county legislators and the state-appointed fiscal monitor (NIFA) say assessed values have been kept frozen in recent years, without a full countywide reassessment. NIFA announced an audit of the Department of Assessment in January 2026.
What it means for you: values that haven't kept up with sales leave some neighborhoods over-assessed relative to others. That's what comps reveal. As reported, not an official county statement
Which form
AR1 · AR2 · AR3
- AR1: value of a 1–3 family home or a Class 1 condo unit
- AR2: value of all other property (commercial, rentals, co-op buildings, vacant land)
- AR3: tax class, exemptions and other non-value claims. Send its supporting proof to the Department of Assessment, not ARC
Contesting value and a non-value issue takes two separate applications.
Commercial (Class 4)
Income is the case
ARC's standard request for income property includes:
- A rent roll as of January 1 of each year under review (all space, including vacant and owner-occupied)
- An itemized income and expense statement for each year, and at least two years
- Abstracts of leases of one year or more (not needed for leases under $25,000 a year)
- Sale contracts or closing statements, permits and construction costs, and environmental or structural plans, where they apply
Separately, the county requires a yearly income and expense statement from most income-producing property. Due date not confirmed on a county page
Villages & cities
Separate assessors
The City of Glen Cove, the City of Long Beach and most incorporated villages set their own assessments for their own taxes. Filing with ARC does not preserve your rights on those. You grieve them with the local Board of Assessment Review, on its own dates. Village boards typically meet the third Tuesday of February, but confirm with your village clerk.
Filing window · 2028/29 roll
43
Filing opens in 43 days.
The Nassau ARC window for the 2028/29 roll opens January 4, 2027 at 9 AM, when AROW opens, and closes March 1, 2027 at 11:59 PM. File online, or by mail postmarked that day. ARC's FAQ says there is no extension. ARC can move a deadline. Check the county calendar.