Screens comparable sales
The check and the comps sheet take the first five similar sales: same class, distance, size, lot, and age, from the past two years. The list is ordered by similarity, not by the lowest price.
Our method
How an assessed value becomes an implied market value, a recommended ask, and the steps on the county form. Estimates, not a promise.
The records
The lookup, the sales screen, and the guide read the assessment roll, the grievance history, and the deed sales, then show a number you can check.
These steps run on the records. A language model only rewrites the signed-in helper's wording, and a rewrite that adds a number is discarded.
The check and the comps sheet take the first five similar sales: same class, distance, size, lot, and age, from the past two years. The list is ordered by similarity, not by the lowest price.
The free check page and the comps sheet label the assessment likely over-assessed, borderline, or at or below ARC's level, once three sales match. A separate lookup response uses over, slightly over, or at or below similar sales. No page prints that second label.
The lookup response includes the years filed, ARC and SCAR, the outcome, and the change in assessed value when the record has it. No page on this site prints that response. The check page shows neighbor filing counts, not this home's year-by-year history.
Total tax divided by the market value on the roll. The same rate is the median on the town and school pages.
The comps sheet sets the suggested assessment at the indicated sale value times the ARC ratio. The free check page shows that same number under Assessment to request. The $100 guide writes it as the recommended ask. A condition note is not turned into a dollar adjustment.
Most free tools show only your current assessment. The assessment rolls, the grievance and appeal history, and the deed sales we hold are in one place.
| Dataset | Here | A typical free tool |
|---|---|---|
| Roll history | Assessed value and market value, final rolls 2021/22–2026/27 and tentative rolls 2022/23–2027/28 | Current assessment |
| Grievance and appeal history | Filings, ARC and SCAR, and the outcome when the record has one, ARC 2004/05–2027/28, SCAR 1993/94–2026/27, court cases from 1958/59 | Not shown |
| Deed sales | Arm's-length sales, with foreclosure, short sale, family, and damaged transfers set aside | Not shown |
| STAR | The exemption on the roll, when the roll has it | Not shown |
| Tax rates | School tax, general tax, and the effective rate | Not shown |
These are the rules the sales screen runs, and the filing steps on the how-to-file page and the math page. Where the screen and those steps differ, the difference is written here. Estimates, not a promise that the assessment will fall.
A comparable is a home that actually sold. A listing is not a comparable, and neither is the assessment on a home that has not sold.
Other sales have to fall inside 24 months, measured back from today's New York date. The home being grieved is the exception. Its own purchase counts at any date, if the price is above zero and the sale passes the test below. That purchase is evidence for the application. It is not one of the five comparables. When a home sold more than once, only the latest sale is used.
Only arm's-length sales are used. Family and related-party transfers, foreclosures, short sales, bank-owned (REO) sales, and damaged homes or teardowns are set aside. The names on the deed are never read. When a sale cannot be confirmed either way, it is kept and labeled arm's-length not confirmed. It is never called confirmed. The free check, the comps sheet, the filing helper, the $100 guide, and the town and school pages all use this same test.
The five sales are the closest qualifying sales this search returns. Qualifying means a sold home, inside two years, not rejected by the arm's-length test above, the same property class, then the closest match on distance, living area, lot, age, and school district. The list is not hand-picked for the lowest price. These five can differ from the sales the county's own portal suggests.
The public lookup, the check page, and the comps sheet use these steps. The search stops at the first step that has 5 sales. It never sorts by the lowest price.
With a map point, the database only loads sales inside 1.5 miles, so the screen does not see the whole county. Without a map point, distance is skipped and the sale has to be in the same school district or the same town. The property class code has to match. A blank class matches nothing.
Among the sales that pass a step, the five with the lowest similarity score are kept. A different school district adds 20. A different class adds 25. The living-area gap, as a fraction of this home, is multiplied by 40, and a missing living area adds 15. The lot gap is multiplied by 15 when both lots are known. A missing lot adds nothing. Each year of age difference adds half a point, up to 30, and a missing year adds 4. About one point is added per month since the sale. Each mile adds 20, and a missing map point adds 8. Ties go to the newer sale.
The written steps also say to look at style. This screen has no style field. The signed-in filing helper uses this same screen. Its five sales are these five.
On the signed-in comps sheet, and in the data for the $100 guide, each of those sales gets one sentence: distance, living area, age, class, sale date, and the arm's-length flag. Each also gets a similarity score from 0 to 100, using distance, living area, lot, year built, class, and how recent the sale is. A score under 60 is marked weak. The sale stays in the five. Up to 3 other sales that pass the same exclusions and score as more similar are listed beside the five, labeled also supports your case when the price is below the implied value, and for reference when it is not. They are not swapped in.
Implied market value is assessed value divided by the level of assessment. Our Emerald Methodology keeps 2026/27 at 0.06%, a multiplier of about 1,666, and 2027/28 at 0.054%, a multiplier of about 1,852. The 2028/29 level is not published. Until it is, the lookup, the check, and the comps sheet divide by 0.054%, the Class 1 level ARC applied for 2027/28. That is the same 0.054% in the level table.
The county's published Class 1 level for the 2027/28 roll is 0.1%. Market value stored on the roll uses that level. The sales test does not. Sales are tested against the ARC figure. SCAR used 0.057% for 2027/28.
Indicated value is the median price per square foot times this home's living area, or the median sale price when living area is missing. The lookup response compares the implied market value with that indicated value. More than 5% above the sales is labeled over. Above the sales, and at or under 5%, is slightly over. At or below the sales stays at or below. One sale is enough for that label. No page on this site prints that label. The address box does not call that lookup.
The free check page and the comps sheet run a second test on the assessed value itself. It waits for at least three sales. Likely over-assessed means the assessed value is more than 5% above the indicated value times 0.057%. Between that and the ARC ratio, 0.054%, the label is borderline. At or below the ARC ratio, the label is at or below ARC's level. That 5% band is ours. The check page also says how far the county's 0.1% market figure sits from the sales. That percentage is not the ARC comparison.
The comps sheet's recommended ask is the indicated value times the ARC ratio, 0.054%, rounded to a whole assessment. The $100 guide includes that ask. The free lookup does not print it.
Example only. Not a real home, a real sale, or a real address. Assessed value 540. Implied market value 540 ÷ 0.00054 = $1,000,000. 3 example sales at $800,000 with the same living area. Indicated value $800,000. The implied value is 25% above those sales, so the lookup response's label is about 25% over similar sales. The check page and the comps sheet use a different label. On these 3 sales that label is Likely over-assessed. The assessment at the ARC ratio, which the comps sheet calls the suggested ask, is $800,000 × 0.00054 = 432.
The signed-in helper prints two other figures from the same sales. Using this example's own roll ratio, assessed value 540 against a roll market value of $540,000, the claimed assessment is 800. The methodology block also prints an ask range 30% to 35% below the fair assessment of 432, which is 281 to 302. Those are not the comps-sheet ask.
Comparables are sold homes only. An unsold neighbor with a lower assessment is not a comparable. Other sales are from the past two years. This home's own purchase can be older. Complete Part D. List every other fact that affects value, with photos and a cost estimate. If the home was bought or listed in the last three years below the implied market value, state that price. Add a good sale the county locator missed. File every year. Nothing here promises a reduction.
A condition note is not turned into a dollar adjustment. Outdated interiors, a flood zone, unrepaired damage, a busy road, a house that needs to be elevated, and any other fact that would change the sale price belong in Part D, with photos and a cost estimate. The screen does not price them.
Our Emerald Methodology turns an assessed value into what that number implies a home is worth, a recommended ask, and the steps on the county form. These are estimates. Check the level of assessment, the rate, the caps, and the deadline with the county before you rely on a dollar figure. This is not legal or tax advice, and it is not a promise that your assessment will fall.
The guide
$100
A flat fee for the written guide. The property lookup is free. Not a percentage of any tax savings.
A written, professionally formatted, paginated PDF guide made for your property. You file the grievance. We do not file it for you.
You file the grievance yourself
You file it yourself, and we show you exactly how.
Filing with ARC is free, and you do not need a lawyer. The $100 pays for the analysis, the comparable sales, and the step-by-step guide. It does not pay for filing. It does not pay us to send the form, and it does not buy a result.
Tax bill
AV × rate / 100
A tax bill cannot be appealed. Only the assessed value can. Assessed value is a point count, not a dollar amount. A home assessed at 500 has 500 points.
665 × 2,339 ÷ 100 = $15,554
The tax bill is taxable assessed value times the rate, divided by 100. On a 2021 example, 665 points at $2,339 per $100 is 665 × 2,339 ÷ 100 = $15,554.
The tentative assessed value is the number the county proposes each January. That is the number you grieve.
You can move the points. The school district sets the rate.
Assessed value to market value
AV ÷ level
The level of assessment is the ratio of assessed value to market value. The multiplier is 1 divided by that level. Assessed value times the multiplier is the implied market value. The same result is assessed value divided by the level.
1,666For 2026/27 the model uses a level of 0.06%, so the multiplier is about 1,666.
1,852For 2027/28 the model uses a level of 0.054%, so the multiplier is about 1,852. An assessed value of 500 × 1,852 is $926,000. Dividing 500 by 0.00054, which is the same level written as a decimal, is $925,926.
An offer of 1,040 points for 2027/28 is 1,040 ÷ 0.00054 = $1,925,926. If the house is worth less than that, it is still over-assessed.
One 2024 purchase, multiplied by 1,666, landed 22% above the price that was paid. That home was over-assessed.
Fair assessed value is the comparable value times the level. Over-assessment is (implied value − comparable value) ÷ comparable value.
If the implied value is above what similar homes sold for, file. If it is not, file anyway while the roll is stale. This filing season is the 2028/29 roll. The 2028/29 level of assessment is not published yet. The model's level table is historical. For 2027/28, ARC applies 0.054% for Class 1, and SCAR used 0.057%. The county's published Class 1 level for the 2027/28 roll is 0.1%. Use the figure the county is applying for the year you are grieving.
The levy is the dollar amount the district must raise. It is set by the budget. Assessments do not change the levy. They change how that fixed amount is split.
The rate is levy ÷ roll × 100. The roll is the sum of taxable assessed value. When winners remove points, the rate rises for everyone.
The rate increase is points removed ÷ (roll − points removed). A non-filer's bill rises by that full increase. A filer's bill changes by (1 + increase) × (1 − their reduction) − 1.
Rockville Centre, 2026/27: filers removed 359,580 points and the rate rose 9.49%. Working backward, the roll was about 4.15 million.
A filer comes out ahead of their old bill only if their reduction is bigger than increase ÷ (1 + increase). Any reduction still helps next to a neighbor who did not file.
| Neighbor | Assessed value | New bill | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Non-filer | 500 | $10,949 | +9.49% |
| Filer, 10% cut | 450 | $9,854 | −1.46% |
60%About 60% of homeowners file, and about 80% of filers win (Newsday, 2025). That is about 230,000 grievances a year, compared with 116,000 in 2011.
6%While the roll is frozen or out of date, standing still costs more. The shift raises the rate. The cap lets an unchallenged assessed value rise as much as 6% in a year. Most people who file win something, so the people who do not file carry the difference.
Every yearFile every year until the system is fixed. Each year is its own appeal. Low-filing districts, Roosevelt and Elmont in the 2026/27 cards, are where a non-filer loses the most ground to neighbors.
These percentages are the assessed-value cut needed just to keep the first-year bill flat. They are not a forecast of what you will get. The worked case is Franklin Square's 6.66% rate increase on a $10,000 bill.
A Class 1 assessed value cannot rise more than 6% in one year or 20% over five years. New construction and renovations are outside the cap and can jump. For example, one new build went from 363 to 1,170 assessed points.
Filing shares run from 74.5% in Rockville Centre (4,243 of 5,697) to 23.5% in Roosevelt (1,024). A dash means that card did not report the figure.
| District | Filed | Assessed value removed | Reported effect |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rockville Centre | 74.5% (4,243/5,697) | 359,580 | rate +9.49% |
| Herricks | 71% (about 6,000) | 513,000 | — |
| Great Neck | 70% (7,921/11,277) | about 1.14 million | typical non-filer +$1,134 |
| Bellmore-Merrick CHSD | 67.2% (15,702) | 781,923 | — |
| Seaford | 65.6% (3,732/5,690) | 186,699 | typical non-filer +$753 |
| Franklin Square | 59% of 7,616 | — | rate +6.66% (about $347) |
| Massapequa | — | — | rate +6.82%, $693 at assessed value 514 |
| Oceanside | — | — | grievance-driven rate +7.14% |
| Elmont | 38% (4,685/12,322) | 193,551 | rate +3.39% |
| Roosevelt | 23.5% (1,024) | 11,814 | — |
Sources